“I thought about making stuff, but it’s easier to buy” Posts to Ponder

by Joseph Flaherty on January 2, 2012

Maker and educator extraordinaire Chris Connors shared this tweet which was presumably about making vs. buying gifts for Christmas. It is an interesting insight into the psychology of someone who is interested in making stuff, but see’s more barriers than opportunities.

+ Tools – This is a major barrier for many people and few are lucky enough to have a well appointed workshop, but there is always the Singer Problem. If tools were the major problem, why don’t more people sew their own clothes (sewing machines are cheap and wide spread), experiment more with cooking, or create computer graphics master pieces.

+ Supplies – Again, there is a kernel of truth here, and you may not be able to cheaply and readily source exotic hardwoods or performance thermoplastics, but fabric, food, and pixels are all affordable.

+ Time – I think this is the biggest creativity and maker killer. At the most basic level, you can interpret this as the time it takes to actually make one widget, but there are many other facets:

+ Procrastination – It’s easy to put off making forcing you to buy something at the last minute. I think this tendency to put things off has its basis in fear. Fear of:

+ Ideas – Will I think of a clever enough idea?

+ Quality – Will I be able to execute this well? What if I invest a couple hours and my product isn’t impressive enough?

A little bit of fear and trepidations is probably a good thing in the world of DIY, otherwise we’d be flooded with horribly knit sweaters and inedible fruit cakes, but removing fear and maybe giving people “Hand Turkeys” we could help amplify new voices and create new customers.

 

 

  • http://grathio.com Steve Hoefer

    I wonder if anyone is willing to do a survey on this? And if people are aware enough of why they don’t make things to make a survey valuable.

    I like to think I make things when I know they don’t exist, or don’t exist in the way that I would like. And that I buy things when they already exist exactly as I want them.

    However those thoughts don’t match reality, at least not all the time. I own a nice sewing machine and I know how to use it. I hate shopping for clothes because I never find what I like. And I don’t mind that sewing is “girly” because sewing machines are incredibly fun power tools, and frankly guys are missing out not using it.

    And yet I don’t make my own clothes.  I’m a walking, talking Singer problem. And I don’t know why.

    It’s not about skill or quality, since I’m willing to bodge together an electronics project without really knowing what I’m doing, and then show off the result. And the stuff I do sew (usually utility stuff) is well made and uses the same techniques as stuff you wear.

    I was ready to say it’s a lack of a safety net. If I get stuck I don’t have a fallback.  Compared to all the smart people, books, and online resources for electronics, I’m adrift for sewing. Yet I do have those resoruces. I’m related to several fantastic sewers, and the net is full of excellent how to  articles and videos. And unlike electronics I can always go to the sewing store and ask an expert in person.

    So I still don’t know why I don’t make my own clothes. Perhaps I just ran out of excuses…

  • http://justindunham.net Justin Dunham

    This is a fascinating problem, which I’m trying to solve (for everyone) right now. Even if you don’t task yourself with having to come up with a clever original project idea, the DIY hump is hard to get over. I think the biggest problem might be self-confidence; perhaps not as true for people who are used to making, but for new DIYers there’s a tremendous cognitive load difference between “I’ll make this” vs. “I’ll listen to this marketing message”.

  • http://www.replicatorinc.com/ Joseph Flaherty

    Justin, Thanks for stopping by! I’d be very interested to learn more about your kit plans. I think we have a lot of common interests between food and DIY. Love your blog’s name BTW.

  • http://www.replicatorinc.com/ Joseph Flaherty

    Steve, Thanks for the introspection. There is some deep human psychology to wrestle with in the “Singer Problem”. It could just as easily be applied to cooking and obesity. Losing weight requires no tools, just willingness to make change and adopt a new mindset, but unfortunately 66% of Americans are still overweight or obese. 

    I think a big part of the problem is just getting people started. I work with a lot of people who are trying to battle Type 2 diabetes and they are often surprised how easy it can be to lose 10-20 pounds just by eliminating soda and candybars from their diet and taking an evening stroll. My guess is that there is a similar hurdle in DIY. 

    I hadn’t soldered for close to 20 years, but then I bought a MakerBot, watched a couple videos on YouTube, and feel like I could conquer any electronics project now. Before that it just seemed like so much to learn, but in retrospect it took all of 30 minutes.

    It makes you wonder how much more is within your grasp than you might expect. Could I replace my floors, fix my car, sew a new jacket (or at least repair my backpack)? Maybe. Right now all three seem like big challenges and time sinks. I’m just waiting for a resource to show me how wrong I am!

  • http://www.replicatorinc.com/ Joseph Flaherty

    Steve, Thanks for the introspection. There is some deep human psychology to wrestle with in the “Singer Problem”. It could just as easily be applied to cooking and obesity. Losing weight requires no tools, just willingness to make change and adopt a new mindset, but unfortunately 66% of Americans are still overweight or obese. 

    I think a big part of the problem is just getting people started. I work with a lot of people who are trying to battle Type 2 diabetes and they are often surprised how easy it can be to lose 10-20 pounds just by eliminating soda and candybars from their diet and taking an evening stroll. My guess is that there is a similar hurdle in DIY. 

    I hadn’t soldered for close to 20 years, but then I bought a MakerBot, watched a couple videos on YouTube, and feel like I could conquer any electronics project now. Before that it just seemed like so much to learn, but in retrospect it took all of 30 minutes.

    It makes you wonder how much more is within your grasp than you might expect. Could I replace my floors, fix my car, sew a new jacket (or at least repair my backpack)? Maybe. Right now all three seem like big challenges and time sinks. I’m just waiting for a resource to show me how wrong I am!

  • http://grathio.com Steve Hoefer

    It often seems like the difficulty is finding that eureka moment, that little crevice in the brick wall where light shines out.  A friend was teaching a class of high school troublemakers (they’d been pulled from other classes for being too disruptive or difficult) and on this particular day they were dead set against learning fractions.  Until she brought in 2 leather jackets, one was 10% off $80 and one was 40% off $150. Suddenly they were all interested in figuring out which was cheaper. By the end of the class they all knew fractions.

    I had the same kind of thing happen with Arduino. Even though I had worked professionally with similar devices, and the Arduino is made specifically to be beginner friendly, I was mystified and intimidated by it. Until I happend to visit a friend who was working on an Arduino robot. In about 30 seconds he explained it in a way that opened the flood gates.

    I think a lot of focus in the DIY space right now is on finding the eureka moments for people.  As you said, after that you can conquer anything.

  • http://grathio.com Steve Hoefer

    It often seems like the difficulty is finding that eureka moment, that little crevice in the brick wall where light shines out.  A friend was teaching a class of high school troublemakers (they’d been pulled from other classes for being too disruptive or difficult) and on this particular day they were dead set against learning fractions.  Until she brought in 2 leather jackets, one was 10% off $80 and one was 40% off $150. Suddenly they were all interested in figuring out which was cheaper. By the end of the class they all knew fractions.

    I had the same kind of thing happen with Arduino. Even though I had worked professionally with similar devices, and the Arduino is made specifically to be beginner friendly, I was mystified and intimidated by it. Until I happend to visit a friend who was working on an Arduino robot. In about 30 seconds he explained it in a way that opened the flood gates.

    I think a lot of focus in the DIY space right now is on finding the eureka moments for people.  As you said, after that you can conquer anything.

  • http://grathio.com Steve Hoefer

    It often seems like the difficulty is finding that eureka moment, that little crevice in the brick wall where light shines out.  A friend was teaching a class of high school troublemakers (they’d been pulled from other classes for being too disruptive or difficult) and on this particular day they were dead set against learning fractions.  Until she brought in 2 leather jackets, one was 10% off $80 and one was 40% off $150. Suddenly they were all interested in figuring out which was cheaper. By the end of the class they all knew fractions.

    I had the same kind of thing happen with Arduino. Even though I had worked professionally with similar devices, and the Arduino is made specifically to be beginner friendly, I was mystified and intimidated by it. Until I happend to visit a friend who was working on an Arduino robot. In about 30 seconds he explained it in a way that opened the flood gates.

    I think a lot of focus in the DIY space right now is on finding the eureka moments for people.  As you said, after that you can conquer anything.

  • http://grathio.com Steve Hoefer

    It often seems like the difficulty is finding that eureka moment, that little crevice in the brick wall where light shines out.  A friend was teaching a class of high school troublemakers (they’d been pulled from other classes for being too disruptive or difficult) and on this particular day they were dead set against learning fractions.  Until she brought in 2 leather jackets, one was 10% off $80 and one was 40% off $150. Suddenly they were all interested in figuring out which was cheaper. By the end of the class they all knew fractions.

    I had the same kind of thing happen with Arduino. Even though I had worked professionally with similar devices, and the Arduino is made specifically to be beginner friendly, I was mystified and intimidated by it. Until I happend to visit a friend who was working on an Arduino robot. In about 30 seconds he explained it in a way that opened the flood gates.

    I think a lot of focus in the DIY space right now is on finding the eureka moments for people.  As you said, after that you can conquer anything.

Previous post:

Next post: